StonePath Investigations LLC
    Back to Blog
    Asset Recovery

    Reaching Exchange-Held Crypto After Judgment: CPLR 5222 Restraining Notices and Turnover Proceedings in New York

    By StonePath Investigations, LLC · NYS-licensed PI firm · CAMS, CFE, TRM CI

    New York courthouse connected through a locked legal document to an exchange dashboard and a chain of blocks

    A New York money judgment is not a remote control for a cryptocurrency exchange. It establishes an enforceable obligation, but it does not automatically identify or freeze digital assets held in a debtor’s custodial account. Reaching those assets generally requires a deliberate Article 52 strategy: identify the relevant property or debt, serve valid process on the right entity, and seek turnover through the appropriate procedure.

    For New York counsel handling crypto investigations judgments, the practical issue is not simply whether a debtor used cryptocurrency. It is whether the available evidence connects the debtor to an account or property interest that New York enforcement process can reach.

    The starting point: crypto as intangible personal property

    New York's enforcement statutes predate blockchain technology by decades, and they reach digital assets anyway. The reach comes from classification and statutory breadth, not from any crypto-specific rule.

    CPLR 5201(b) makes a money judgment enforceable against any interest of the judgment debtor in personal property. New York courts treat cryptocurrency as intangible personal property, which places exchange balances squarely inside the Article 52 framework. That classification matters procedurally. Intangible property is levied on by service of an execution on the person holding it, not by the sheriff physically seizing anything, and it is the subject of turnover orders rather than sheriffs' sales.

    The distinction between exchange-held and self-custodied assets flows from the same logic. An exchange balance is, in substance, a custodial obligation the platform owes its customer, which means there is a third party to serve. A self-custody wallet is controlled by a private key, which means there may be no one to serve but the debtor. Warner & Scheuerman's guide to enforcing New York judgments against crypto holdings frames the analysis the same way: identify who controls the asset, determine whether a garnishee exists, and choose the enforcement tool accordingly.

    Judgment, restraint, turnover: three different instruments

    Here is the trap: counsel who treat a restraining notice as if it were a collection order, or a turnover motion as if it were self-executing, discover the gap only after the debtor's balance has been withdrawn. Article 52 tools do different jobs, and picking the wrong one wastes weeks the debtor can spend moving coins.

    A money judgment does not itself direct a centralized exchange to immobilize a customer's crypto. A restraining notice under CPLR 5222 may restrain the debtor and, when properly served, a third party holding the debtor's property or owing a debt to the debtor. But a restraint is a freeze, not a transfer to the creditor.

    The next step may be an execution and levy, or a court proceeding seeking payment or delivery of property. The route depends in part on what the exchange holds and the legal relationship between the customer and the exchange. A balance shown in an account interface is evidence to investigate, not a complete legal description of the asset.

    CPLR 5222: the restraint and its limits

    A restraining notice prohibits transferring, paying, or otherwise disposing of covered property or debts until the judgment is satisfied or vacated, subject to the statute's terms. For a third-party custodian, the notice concerns property in its possession or custody in which the debtor is known or reasonably believed to have an interest, as well as qualifying debts owed to the debtor.

    The mechanics are fast compared to a motion practice cycle, and that speed is the point. A properly issued and served notice can immobilize a custodial balance before the debtor realizes enforcement has begun.

    The statute permits issuance by the court clerk or the judgment creditor’s attorney acting as an officer of the court. That is not the same as saying a particular checked-box “notice of services” form is a statutory prerequisite. The controlling requirements are the statute’s required contents, valid issuance, and proper service. Counsel should verify the notice and service method against the current CPLR and the facts of the matter; a form label does not cure a defective notice.

    A critical timing distinction is often misstated: a restraining notice served on a third-party garnishee generally expires one year after service, or earlier if the judgment is satisfied or vacated. A notice served on the judgment debtor is treated differently. The statute does not establish a general two-year restraint period for exchange-held assets. The “two” that can arise in this context concerns other statutory limits, including restrictions on the number of certain notices, not a two-year garnishee freeze.

    Two provisions in the same subdivision deserve attention in a crypto matter, because both cut against an overbroad notice. First, if a garnishee served with a restraining notice withholds money owed to the debtor in an amount equal to twice the amount due on the judgment, the restraint is not effective as to other property or money. That is a ceiling on how much a custodian must hold, not a target to aim at. Second, a judgment creditor who specifies particular personal property or a particular debt in the notice is liable to the owner of that property or the person to whom the debt is owed, if that person is someone other than the debtor, for damages sustained by reason of the restraint.

    The second point is the one to think through before naming a wallet. Where attribution is still an inference rather than a documented conclusion, a notice that specifies an address or a deposit path can create exposure if the property turns out to belong to a third party. Specificity is a virtue in a restraining notice and a liability in a bad one, and the difference is the quality of the underlying attribution evidence.

    The restraint also does not eliminate the need to consider the amount restrained, competing ownership interests, or statutory protections. For example, separate exemption procedures may apply to certain bank-account restraints involving natural persons. Counsel should assess whether those protections apply to the property and institution at issue rather than assume that every exchange account is treated like a bank account.

    Choosing an exchange as a service target

    An exchange’s New York regulatory status can help identify an entity with a meaningful New York connection, but a BitLicense or New York trust charter is not itself a collection remedy. It does not establish that a particular debtor has an account there, prove the balance belongs to the debtor, or replace proper service and jurisdictional analysis.

    Counsel should identify the precise legal entity that operates the relevant service, its custody role, and the appropriate service channel. The NYDFS virtual currency business directory is a useful starting point for checking regulatory status. It is a starting point, not a substitute for confirming the entity and its relationship to the account.

    The procedural questions are distinct:

    Is the entity holding property in which the debtor has an interest?

    Does it owe the debtor a debt, such as an account balance payable under its customer agreement?

    What evidence supports the identification of the debtor, the relevant wallet or deposit address, and the exchange account?

    Is the proposed service method valid for this entity and notice?

    That last step matters. A well-supported trace aimed at the wrong corporate entity is still aimed at the wrong target.

    The levy: CPLR 5230 and 5232 after the freeze

    A restraint freezes an account, but it does not move money. Moving money requires an execution and a levy, and the two instruments are governed by separate sections.

    An execution under CPLR 5230 is issued by the clerk of the court or by the judgment creditor's attorney acting as an officer of the court, directed to the sheriff. The statute prescribes its contents: the court and date the judgment was entered, the amount due, the applicable interest rate, the parties, and the debtor's last known address. Defects in those contents give a garnishee a reason to reject process, which is why the document deserves the same scrutiny as the restraining notice.

    The levy itself is governed by CPLR 5232. Subdivision (a) covers exactly the situation an exchange presents: intangible property and debts owed to the judgment debtor. The sheriff levies by serving a copy of the execution on the garnishee in the same manner as a summons. Once served, the garnishee must transfer the property and pay the debts to the sheriff, and it is forbidden from releasing anything to anyone else, including the debtor, while the levy stands.

    Timing discipline matters here, because two clocks run at once. The CPLR 5222 restraint on a third-party garnishee expires one year after service, or earlier if the judgment is satisfied or vacated. The CPLR 5232 levy lapses ninety days after service unless the property has been transferred to the sheriff or a turnover proceeding under CPLR 5225 or 5227 has been brought. The practical lesson is that a freeze buys a window, not an outcome. If the levy is served and nothing follows, the exchange can lawfully release the balance when the window closes.

    CPLR 5225 and 5227: seeking delivery or payment

    CPLR 5225 provides different procedures depending on who possesses the property. Subdivision (a) addresses property in the judgment debtor’s possession. Subdivision (b) addresses property in the possession or custody of another person, or property transferred to a transferee. In a third-party custody situation, the creditor may commence a special proceeding and ask the court to direct delivery of property or payment of money, subject to the statutory showing and the parties’ rights.

    CPLR 5227 addresses a person who is or will become indebted to the judgment debtor. That may be relevant where the dispute concerns a payment obligation or account balance rather than a claim to particular crypto held in custody. Whether 5225, 5227, or another enforcement step fits depends on the facts and the legal characterization of the asset or obligation; the labels should not be chosen by habit.

    These are special proceedings against the relevant third party. The judgment debtor must receive the notice required by statute, and the debtor may be permitted to intervene. That notice requirement should not be casually converted into a blanket rule that the debtor must be joined as a party to the original merits action. Counsel should follow the statutory procedure for the particular proceeding and assess any service or jurisdictional objections before seeking relief.

    If a restraining notice does not produce compliance or a transfer, counsel may also assess execution and levy procedures under CPLR 5230 and related provisions. A restraining notice and an execution are different instruments with different functions: one restrains; the other provides a levy mechanism.

    Why tracing evidence comes first

    The procedural vehicle does not supply the missing factual link. A court-facing application is stronger when the record explains why the identified exchange, account, or deposit address is connected to the judgment debtor and the property sought. The question a court will ask is not "can crypto be restrained?" but "why does this record show this debtor's assets at this entity?"

    A litigation-ready tracing report should make the evidentiary path understandable and reproducible. It can document transaction hashes, relevant blockchain networks, timestamps, amounts and asset types, address relationships, exchange deposit indicators, analytical assumptions, and limitations. It should distinguish what the blockchain directly shows from what is inferred through attribution or off-chain records.

    The key questions are concrete: What transaction is being relied on? Which address received the asset? What supports the conclusion that the address is associated with the debtor or the exchange? Does the record establish an account relationship, or only a deposit path that may require further evidence? A clear answer is more useful than a dense diagram that leaves the court to guess.

    This is the role of litigation-ready court documents crypto tracing can support: organizing technical evidence for legal analysis, not substituting for legal conclusions. StonePath’s cryptocurrency investigation methodology combines blockchain analysis with traditional investigative techniques and structured reporting for legal and financial audiences.

    Self-custody: turnover without a garnishee

    An exchange is a third-party custodian; a self-custody wallet has no intermediary to restrain or serve. There is no garnishee for the keys. That absence changes the entire enforcement posture: the creditor cannot freeze the asset through service, because there is no one to serve.

    The route instead runs through CPLR 5225(a). Where the judgment debtor is in possession or custody of personal property in which they have an interest, the court, on motion, orders the debtor to pay money or deliver property sufficient to satisfy the judgment. Applied to self-custodied crypto, that means an order directing the debtor to transfer the coins to a wallet controlled by the creditor or a receiver, or to deliver the keys. Subdivision (c) adds a useful lever: the court can order any person to execute whatever documents are necessary to effect the transfer.

    Compliance is the debtor's problem, and the statute supplies the consequence. Disobedience of a turnover order is punishable as contempt. But the creditor must first show the debtor actually holds the property or controls the keys. A trace that reaches an externally controlled wallet does not, by itself, establish either fact, and an order directed at a debtor who cannot comply is a dead letter. Counsel may need post-judgment disclosure under CPLR 5223 and 5224, deposition testimony about wallets and seed-phrase storage, or other court-authorized discovery before asking for the turnover order.

    Before judgment: attachment under CPLR 6201 where dissipation risk exists

    Everything above assumes a judgment already exists. In a pending action, the analogous tool is pre-judgment attachment under Article 62, and crypto assets raise its profile because they are easy to move and hard to claw back.

    CPLR 6201 lists the grounds for an order of attachment. The most relevant to digital assets is subdivision (3): the defendant, with intent to defraud creditors or frustrate enforcement of a potential judgment, has assigned, disposed of, encumbered, or secreted property, or removed it from the state, or is about to do so. Rapid on-chain movement of funds after a dispute erupts is precisely the fact pattern that ground contemplates, and it requires evidentiary facts, not suspicion, to support the intent element.

    Attachment is also subject to CPLR 6212, which requires a showing of a probable valid cause of action, a likelihood of success on the merits, an amount exceeding counterclaims, and an undertaking. Courts treat attachment as a harsh remedy and construe it narrowly. Two further points deserve attention: the statute excludes matrimonial actions outright, and attachment operates on property rather than people, so its reach depends on where the property sits.

    The enforcement version of the same urgency applies after judgment as well. Crypto does not need a court order to move; a debtor with a phone can relocate a balance between jurisdictions in minutes. That asymmetry is why identification and service should be sequenced deliberately, and why delay after discovery is its own form of risk.

    Where enforcement actually fails: three recurring pitfalls

    The mechanics are settled. The failures are factual and procedural, and they repeat across matters:

    1. The wrong entity served. Exchange groups often operate through multiple legal entities, and the account agreement, not the brand name, identifies the counterparty. A restraining notice served on a holding company or an unrelated subsidiary of the correct brand restrains nothing. Confirm the precise legal entity that operates the service before process issues.

    2. Non-cooperative venues. Offshore platforms without a New York presence raise personal jurisdiction problems over the garnishee, and some platforms read their terms closely, preferring court orders to marshal process. Service on an entity with no New York contacts is unlikely to hold, and an unenforceable restraint wastes the one-year window the statute provides.

    3. Self-custody gaps. Identifying a wallet address is not identifying an asset the law can seize. Without evidence tying the debtor to the keys, a turnover motion asks a court to order someone to do something they may be unable to do, and contempt proceedings premised on inability to comply collapse. Build the control evidence first.

    Each pitfall traces back to the same root: process served on facts that have not been verified. The checklists that follow address how to close that gap.

    Counsel’s practical sequence

    Before seeking to restrain or turn over exchange-held crypto, counsel can use this checklist:

    1. Trace and identify before service. Use off-chain records first: bank statements showing on-ramp transfers to an exchange, card purchases, tax filings, and disclosures. Once a wallet address or account is known, chain analysis links deposits to the platform and identifies preservation targets. Serve process on evidence, not on a hunch.

    2. Identify the entity and custody relationship. Confirm the exchange's legal operator, relevant service entity, and New York regulatory status where applicable.

    3. Build the evidentiary link. Preserve transaction hashes, address data, tracing methodology, source records, and the reasoning connecting the debtor to the account or property.

    4. Choose the correct process. Distinguish an information request, a CPLR 5222 restraint, a CPLR 5230 execution and CPLR 5232 levy, a CPLR 5225 proceeding, and a CPLR 5227 proceeding.

    5. Verify issuance and service. Check statutory contents, the correct recipient, an authorized service method, and the applicable notice period.

    6. Prepare for objections. Anticipate disputes over ownership, exemptions, service, the debtor's interest in the property, and whether the exchange owes a debt or merely holds property.

    7. Preserve a court-usable record. Maintain source materials and clear documentation so the tracing analysis can be reviewed, explained, and, where appropriate, supported by an expert.

    A restraint is a procedural pause, not a recovery order. The durable value lies in matching the legal remedy to the asset relationship and supporting that choice with disciplined, reviewable evidence.

    This article is for educational purposes only. It is not legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is created by it. Statutory descriptions summarize current public texts and general principles; application to a specific matter requires counsel licensed in the relevant jurisdiction.

    If a judgment debtor may be holding crypto on an exchange, the tracing evidence should be in place before a restraining notice is served. Contact StonePath Investigations, LLC to discuss litigation-ready forensic blockchain analysis for judgment enforcement.

    Schedule a Free Consultation
    CallBook a Free Consultation